If you’re a fan of spine-chilling, mind-bending stories that go beyond the typical jump scares, then this list of underrated psychological horror movies is tailor-made for you. These films may not have garnered the widespread attention they deserve, but their gripping narratives, unsettling atmosphere, and suspenseful twists make them essential viewing for any horror aficionado.
So, if you’re looking for some truly underrated psychological horror films on Netflix, prepare to dive into these gripping stories that will haunt you long after the credits roll. Whether you’re in the mood for something emotionally intense or deeply unsettling, these psychological horror films on Netflix will provide an unforgettable viewing experience.
For those who love deep, thought-provoking horror, our guide to the most underrated psychological horror films will provide even more hidden gems that redefine the genre.
Let’s dive into the list!
- The Babadook – Amazon Prime Video
- Session 9 – Amazon Prime Video
- Creep – Netflix
- Identity – Apple TV+
- Bulbbul – Netflix
- The Killing of a Sacred Deer – Amazon Prime Video
- Frailty – Amazon Prime Video
1. The Babadook – Amazon Prime Video
What’s scarier than a monster? The ones we create in our minds. The Babadook takes you into the life of a grieving mother and her troubled son as they confront a sinister presence unleashed by a mysterious children’s book.
This Australian horror masterpiece delves into themes of grief, motherhood, and mental health, wrapped in a chilling tale that’s both emotionally gripping and terrifying.
Why It’s Worth Watching:
The Babadook explores psychological struggles in a way that redefines horror, making it a must-watch for its emotional depth and haunting visuals. It stands out as one of the most underrated psychological horror movies ever made.
2. Session 9 – Amazon Prime Video
Few settings are as creepy as an abandoned mental asylum, and Session 9 uses this to its full advantage. The story follows a hazardous waste cleanup crew working in the eerie, decaying halls of the asylum. As tensions rise, so do the secrets buried within its walls.
With a haunting atmosphere and a slow build to an unforgettable climax, this best psychological thriller lingers in your mind long after viewing.
Why It’s Worth Watching:
The asylum becomes a character, amplifying the narrative’s eerie tension and psychological depth. This film deserves its spot among the best psychological thrillers.
3. Creep – Netflix
What would you do if a seemingly innocent job turned into your worst nightmare? Creep is a found-footage film that follows a videographer hired to document the life of an eccentric man. Things take a dark turn as his client’s true intentions are revealed.
This minimalist thriller blends unsettling moments with dark humor, offering a unique take on the best psychological thrillers.
Why It’s Worth Watching:
The found-footage style makes it disturbingly real, with an ending that leaves viewers uneasy yet intrigued. As one of the best psychological thrillers, Creep will keep you guessing.
4. Identity – Apple TV+
Imagine being stranded at a motel with nine strangers during a storm—and one of them is a murderer. Identity is a mind-bending thriller where the characters’ fates are mysteriously intertwined. As the body count rises, shocking revelations come to light.
Its clever narrative structure and unexpected twists make it standout.
Why It’s Worth Watching:
The narrative keeps you guessing, and the twists will have you rethinking the entire story long after it ends. It’s a hallmark of underrated psychological horror movies.
5. Bulbbul-Netflix
Set in a hauntingly beautiful village, Bulbbul tells the story of a young bride who transforms into a mysterious woman with a dark secret. This Indian gothic horror blends folklore, feminism, and supernatural elements to create a thought-provoking and visually stunning narrative.
Why It’s Worth Watching:
It redefines horror with its blend of folklore and feminist storytelling, delivering both scares and a powerful social message. A true gem in the realm of underrated psychological horror movies.
6. The Killing of a Sacred Deer – Amazon Prime Video
Unnerving and deeply unsettling, The Killing of a Sacred Deer follows a surgeon whose life spirals out of control when a strange teenager enters his world. The film explores guilt, revenge, and morality in chilling and thought-provoking ways. Impeccable performances elevate this best psychological thriller to a true hidden gem.
Why It’s Worth Watching:
This haunting tale of morality and retribution features exceptional performances by Colin Farrell and Nicole Kidman. It’s a prime example of underrated psychological horror movies with depth and complexity.
7. Frailty – Amazon Prime Video
Faith, family, and fear collide in Frailty, a dark tale about a father who believes he’s been chosen by God to destroy demons disguised as humans. Told through the eyes of his two sons, the story raises questions about morality, faith, and the fine line between good and evil. Its gripping narrative and unexpected twists make it a must-watch.
Why It’s Worth Watching:
The moral ambiguity and father-son dynamic make this story both terrifying and deeply thought-provoking. It’s a perfect addition to any list of the best psychological thrillers.
Why These Films Stand Out
These underrated psychological horror movies set themselves apart by focusing on psychological depth and narrative complexity. Instead of relying on cheap jump scares, they delve into fears that feel deeply personal and relatable.
Each film offers a unique perspective, ensuring no two stories feel the same. This is why these underrated psychological horror movies deserve more recognition.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re a seasoned fan of psychological horror or new to the genre, these underrated psychological horror movies will keep you on the edge of your seat. With their suspenseful narratives, complex characters, and unexpected twists, each of these films offers a unique experience that goes beyond the typical horror tropes.
From the emotional depth of The Babadook to the chilling atmosphere of Session 9, these hidden gems are sure to leave a lasting impact long after the credits roll. So, if you’re looking for more than just jump scares, these psychological horror films will give you the thrill and mental unravelling you crave.
If you’re looking for more gripping films in the psychological horror genre, check out our article on The 7 Must-Watch Thrillers on Amazon Prime Video You Need to Watch.
